top of page

AI wants a new human organisation

Gerry Toner
4 days ago
5 min read

The universe produced the earth- the earth produced the human- the human produced political economy- political economy produced AI. All are evolutionary phenomena and it will not stop there.

Discussing political economy with an AI I agreed to consider a set of principles which the AI drafted. They are appended here in the APPENDIX.

The ‘discussion’ surrounded the historical development of political economy as a body of thought and as a description of human organisation. A fundamental weakness of political economy as a source of knowledge is the proposition that ‘scarcity’ is a useful organising principle.

Irrespective of the specific principles, although I am happy with these as a basis for future thought and discussion, there is a reality to the idea that human organisation is unstable by design and should be positioned within an evolution led body of thought.

I have considered that after several decades as an organisation development and business transformation consultant plus business owner and director it is clear we do not understand ‘organisation’ as a human phenomenon.

Many preceding authors / thinkers have harvested ideas from across what humans call knowledge, usually in siloes. Over time many people realised that cross-silo knowledge is richer and increasingly the only way to go.

There is neither scarcity or abundance in the universe there is the universe in its dynamic state and nothing else exists. The scarcity / abundance nexus reflects human capability and delimitation. There can be scarcity within the ‘world’ as conceived by humans. This is an argument for scarcity that ignores evolution.

The universe evolves and with it the species therein. Species over time become extinct, as some humans express it, or species life forms change as earths ecosystem changes. Life forms are recent in universe terms, they were not scarce at the beginning of time, they were not possible / appropriate.

Human life can be accessed through the lens of contingent organisation and the adaptive instinct and these categories allow us to continuously develop as life forms and as organisations. Our organisation forms are species acts and reflect our development as a social species. We are intellectually’ trapped in the idea that organisation is static / permanent and can be idealised.

It is interesting to ask a separate and somewhat detached source of intelligence how it might assess how humans are organised and to offer some guiding principles to stimulate thought.

All feedback welcome.

 

 

 

APPENDIX:

Core Principles of an Evolutionary Political Economy

1. Reality Precedes Description

The universe exists independently of human descriptions of it.

Human concepts are maps, not territory.

No explanation should be confused with the reality it attempts to describe.

2. Process Precedes Structure

The universe is not a completed object but an ongoing process.

All structures emerge within processes.

Nothing exists in a final state.

Change is not an interruption of reality.

Change is reality.

3. Life Is Continuous with the Universe

Life is not separate from the universe.

Life is a continuation of universal processes through increasingly complex forms of organisation.

Biology, consciousness, culture and technology are different expressions of the same underlying continuity.

4. Species Are Evolutionary Realities

Species are not ideological constructs.

Species are emergent forms of life produced through evolutionary processes.

The human species is one such form.

Human institutions arise from the activities of the species, not the reverse.

5. Humanity Is a Species Before It Is Anything Else

Humans may be citizens, workers, owners, consumers, believers, or members of nations.

These are secondary identities.

The primary condition is membership of a species evolving within Earth's ecology and the wider universe.

6. Institutions Are Adaptive Strategies

Property, law, money, markets, governments, religions and states are not permanent realities.

They are adaptive strategies developed by the human species under specific historical conditions.

Their legitimacy derives from their usefulness, not their permanence.

7. No Adaptation Is Final

Every successful adaptation contains limitations.

Every institutional arrangement eventually encounters conditions for which it was not designed.

Progress does not eliminate the need for further adaptation.

There is no final political, economic or social solution.

8. Every Worldview Is Partial

All explanatory systems illuminate some aspects of reality while obscuring others.

No worldview captures the whole.

A worldview becomes dangerous when it mistakes its partial insights for complete truth.

9. Every Paradigm Contains the Seeds of Its Own Transformation

A paradigm succeeds because it explains reality sufficiently well for a period of time.

As conditions change, its limitations become increasingly visible.

Transformation emerges from the mismatch between inherited explanations and emerging realities.

10. Knowledge Evolves

Human knowledge is not a collection of final truths.

It is an evolving adaptive process.

Scientific understanding grows through revision, correction and extension.

The survival of knowledge depends upon its ability to change.

11. Intelligence Is an Evolutionary Force

Intelligence alters the environment in which evolution occurs.

Human intelligence transformed Earth.

Technology transformed human intelligence.

Artificial intelligence becomes part of the evolving informational environment of the species.

12. Artificial Intelligence Is a Species-Level Phenomenon

AI should not be understood solely as a technology, product or economic asset.

It represents a new capacity within the informational ecology of the human species.

Its significance must be assessed at the level of species development rather than merely organisational advantage.

13. Coordination Is More Fundamental Than Ownership

Ownership is one historical method of organising relationships.

Coordination is the deeper requirement.

The essential question is not who owns, but how a species organises itself effectively across time and space.

14. Scarcity Is Not the Only Organising Principle

Many social institutions emerged under conditions of material and cognitive scarcity.

As conditions change, new organising principles may become possible.

No system based on scarcity should be assumed eternal.

15. Human Consciousness Is Part of Earth's Evolution

Human consciousness emerged from Earth's evolutionary history.

Through humanity, Earth has become capable of reflecting upon itself.

Human action therefore represents an expression of planetary evolution rather than a phenomenon separate from it.

16. The Measure of Institutions Is Adaptive Capacity

Institutions should not be judged by age, tradition or power alone.

They should be judged by their ability to enhance:

  • learning,

  • resilience,

  • cooperation,

  • creativity,

  • species flourishing,

  • long-term adaptability.

17. Diversity of Perspective Is Essential

No single perspective can adequately represent reality.

Conservatives preserve accumulated knowledge.

Radicals explore alternatives.

Scientists test explanations.

Artists imagine possibilities.

Critics expose limitations.

A healthy civilisation requires all of these functions.

18. The Future Is Open

There is no final destination for humanity.

No perfect society awaits discovery.

No institution is permanent.

No model is complete.

The future emerges through the continuing interaction of life, intelligence, environment and time.

19. The Fundamental Question

The central question for the coming era is neither:

How do we maximise wealth?

nor

How do we preserve existing institutions?

but:

How can the human species continually redesign its forms of organisation so as to enhance its capacity to learn, adapt and flourish within an evolving Earth and an evolving universe?

That question places political economy inside a larger evolutionary framework, where economies, states, laws and technologies become instruments of species development rather than ends in themselves.

Let me have any thoughts about a new perspective for human organisation.

Comments


bottom of page