top of page

Fossil Nations too Anachronistic for AI

Gerry Toner
2h
7 min read

Infrastructure is largely understated but assumed to be there. We are born into human organisation that is rich in physical, digital and social infrastructure. Many take it for granted or like elites cannot value it because it displaces their status. In todays AI rich world 'nations' as organisations do not offer hope of progress but promote despair. In 'AI wants a new human organisation' [LINK] an AI generated set of principles is laid out that reflect the evolutionary context of the human. It is a prompt to us humans to expand our thinking for a much greater appreciation of our potential and for our role in the earths ecosystem.


The idea that the category 'nation' is a sustainable and relevant one for humans to successfully negotiate the future seems to be an anachronism. Most people's lived experience is not of "the nation" but of infrastructure and social relationships:

Transport networks

Close family

Energy systems

Extended family

Communications systems

Neighbours

Payment systems

Tribe / clan etc

Healthcare systems

Belief system/church

Logistics systems

Sports / cultural groups

Scientific knowledge systems

Music

Legal systems

Friendships

Educational systems

Social media

It is infrastructure that is the great achievement of humans. People are born into these accumulated infrastructures and relationships which we largely take for granted. Progressively new humans will be born into an AI grounded world. We should appreciate AI as our intelligence embodied as we have design in software code. we may in time stop calling it 'artificial' intelligence as there is nothing artificial about it. For now we can use AI like we have given it a nickname.

The modern citizen experiences the world through infrastructure and relationships, not through sovereignty. AI is potentially our new global infrastructure partner.


The System of Nations

The Irish band Fontaines DC, has a lyric which goes "In the modern world....I don't feel anything', a quite striking emotional state to convey. In the same lyric a more positive tone is struck by the personal and the individual outlook for love. It carries the cohabiting tension of human lives lived in nations but seeking something more. It used to be that older generations were accepting of their modern lives. The system of nations emerged in the 20th century to offer an expanding global scale horizon to the 'ordinary' citizen. After centuries of colonial expansion and exploitation a consensus descended that the system of nations would be a 'League of Nations' and then 'United Nations'. These emerged as the intensity of war laden governance by mainly aristocrats and other elites was not working, at least not in the newly emerging 'modern world'.

The American Charles Tilly is often quoted for "war made the state and the state made war". We can go back to Francisco de Vittoria (1483-1546) and Hugo Grotius (1583-1645) and his On The Law of War and Peace. These authors are often referred to as the 'fathers of international law'. In other parts of the globe there is Hammurabi, ancient Egypt., Asia and Maya / Aztec people with other forms of governance codes.

The state is a species phenomenon engendered locally in specific forms expressing local and general characteristics. Over time like many social arrangements things change and develop, sometimes for the better but not for all.

 

Literature in this space identifies a progressive 'diffusion' and 'convergence' dynamic at play as each new form of state develops. It must be said here that this 'progression' is a European concept. Vittoria and Grotius were providing religious and legal cover for colonial exploitation of other places.

This literature is itself hegemonic material and activity to strengthen the system of nations as sustainable human organisation. It is also informative and supports our understanding of the earth, which has no borders, and that human organisation is adaptive and contingent. We have devised the 'nation' and the state as methods for organising ourselves. I describe this literature as hegemonic as it seeks to promote and reproduce the nation state as a sustainable mechanism.

 

Alternative visions also exist that do not categorise ‘nations’ as sustainable and also as recognised as hegemonic actions by selection of privileged priorities. This view adopts the approach that free and uncontrolled access to and over resources is the way to organise the life form called humans.

 

Anarchy is a category used by the hegemonic design culture to describe those communities seeking freedom through autonomous and separate organisation. Wallerstein highlights pressure from the system of nations that degrades life in non participating communities. The US at present is declaring an expanding list of nations are rogue or terrorist or other non-compliant status.

 

Global Infrastructure

In the 21st century the system of nations governance includes war and impoverishment through denial mechanisms such as war, genocide, cybercrime, blockade and trade tariffs walls.

 

Has the UN implemented any effective global governance if the dominant nations ignore its decisions? It is clear they have not. Are international treaties real governance or are they hegemonic mechanisms that maintain dominance of partial interests? Is this stasis better viewed as a reset moment that requires a new paradigm.


Brexit may be understood partly as a response to perceived loss of agency and meaning. Many citizens experienced decision-making as increasingly distant, bureaucratic and technocratic. The vote expressed not only economic concerns but a desire for recognition, belonging and participation in shaping collective futures. The Brexit vote is a cry for meaning. Loss of meaning through bureaucracy renders many people vulnerable to political pressure and persuasion to new bargains. Like a retail campaign. The Brexit move and the subsequent actions of the administration in the US suggest reversal to narrow single nation interests is the new thing to do. That also means calling into question the neutrality of global institutions such as-

 

  • WTO

  • World Bank

  • IMF


The EU as a more recent supra-state entity is now challenged by US actions and also the reactions of each nation state. The BRICS collaboration also creates a new reality for how global arrangements. NATO is also now in flux as it is being positioned both as a war machine and as was originally the idea as a protector and peacemaker. The infrastructure of global hegemony must align with the system of nations and thus the dominant nations.


However the experience, the UX ['user experience'] for the citizen is that instability and unreliability are the hallmarks of the system of nations and its leadership cohort. We are only being offered 'methodological nationalism' as the path of progress.

 

It is questionable to perhaps a majority globally, that the system of nations is in fact not a community of people but in reality a cabal or cartel. There are strata in each nation who benefit locally and internationally but increasingly this is a very small proportion of each society.


Democracy is shaped by these strata and their interests/ mechanisms. This also involves international distribution of each domestic model and the dynamic of uneven/ unequal development. The predominant proposition from bourgeois systems is democratic representation. Bourgeois hegemonic narratives assign negative status to other systems such as fascism and totalitarianism.

 

This how hegemonic narrative enables dominance of one over the other systems according to conditions and social strata. The Soviets and The Hitler Fascists did the same thing. The system of nations is a global system developing over time and space. They share integration with the commodity organisation of the global economy along with social democracies and other systems.


The commodity organisation produces all of the models at different times and locations. The commodity organisation is a highly stratified model with global reach. The dominant energy forms around capital in money form and support from property and wage relations. The global system is at any historical point formal and informal in its makeup with dominance appropriated by the formal system. The informal is automatically subordinated to the formal through the state and law.


In each nation the manifest human organisation structures and relations are unique.

 

Oxford Handbook of State Transformation-

“Social structures, and especially socio-economic classes, represent the key intervening variable between economic development and political conflicts. These class structures vary considerably among world regions and countries, in line with their level of economic development. The size of the agrarian sector and the distribution of land are as important in this respect as the size of the informal sector and the timing and scope of the transition to service economies, resulting in more or less deindustrialization. And the size of a middle class with post-secondary education is as important as the dominance of big landowners, industrial entrepreneurs, or financial interests on the side of capital. Hence the analysis of social structures cannot draw on one-size-fits-all class typologies, and an exclusive focus on the working class is inappropriate for the analysis of many countries in the Global South, due to their high shares of informal workers.”

 

AI demands integration and globalisation

Nations promote fragmentation and segmented privilege systems. In an integrated world they offer no path to sustainability. A human individual is a species member and human communities are part of the human species. Our infrastructure should be integrated not fragmented and dysfunctional.

Principles of Post-National Human Organisation

1. Planetary Infrastructure

Humanity increasingly depends upon global systems:

  • climate

  • energy

  • communications

  • finance

  • science

  • AI

Governance must reflect the scale of these systems not just for reasons of execution but also to move on as an intelligent species. The human is the primary catalyst for transforming the earth in the universe.

2. Local Identity

People remain attached to:

  • place

  • culture

  • language

  • history

Greater global integration does not require cultural uniformity. Many people already travel and would travel more if possible. Many more people already connect across the vast space of the globe. The evidence is clear the human likes to interact and to seek reaction. Being local and being connected is grounded in our physical embodiment as a mammal.

3. Shared Knowledge Commons

Knowledge should increasingly be treated as a collective human asset rather than primarily as national or capital asset or property. AI dramatically strengthens this possibility. There is no person who has built the anthology of human knowledge. Knowledge is not created by ego alone. The human individual is not a viable species category. We succeed as a species.

4. Infrastructure Before Sovereignty

The success of social organisation should be measured by the quality of shared infrastructure rather than the power of competing states. Nations were designed at the time of developing new organisation models from the rudiments of feudal agricultural governance and mechanical technologies. We have stretched that model to its limits. There is always a new frontier. We need new super concepts for infrastructure to achieve planetary sustainability and new frontiers in the universe.

5. Species-Level Governance means sharing

Many challenges:

  • climate change

  • pandemics

  • AI

  • biodiversity

  • oceans

  • space

These themes cannot be meaningfully or effectively governed at national scale. The failed Soviet model especially and the broader 'socialism in one country' debate or the economic autarky debate have already been aired in the 20th century and while interesting did not succeed. The failed primarily because of fragmented human organisation. The integration that comes from a global design enables a rethink from a species perspective.

The development of institutions capable of acting on behalf of humanity as a whole becomes an evolutionary necessity rather than an ideological preference.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page